By : Drs. MOHAMMAD ALI SAIDAbstractThe interest in the study of morality has always been one matter of endless discussion since there is no one objective standard of morality. W. Shakespeare wrote Macbeth in relation with the fact that life should not neglect the value of morality. Therefore, this study tries to reveal the moral lesson of main characters reflected in Macbeth and its significance to the recent life phenomena. There are three major moral lessons reflected in this literary work, i.e. power corrupts, temptation of evil, and murder. These lessons, as a matter of fact, are very closely related to the real life that corruption, collusion, nepotism and murder always happen as a result of evils as shown in the story of Macbeth.Key words : morality, power corrupt, prophecy, murderThe discussion on the concept of morality usually leads to somewhat controversial. Historically, the concept of morality has often been used negatively as a list of thou shall not in check against ones actions. The stance taken is often that it does not matter what you do, as long as you do not violate any moral edicts; but the source of these moral edicts is often mystical or arbitrary.
A list of prohibitions, even if founded in reason rather than mysticism, is not a sufficient outline for success. Morality should be positive rather than negative. Not what shouldn’t I do? but What should I do?. The problem defining morality negatively is that pretty much anything goes provided one avoids a few problem areas. This is not useful because within the sphere of pretty much anything goes, there is no methodical way to choose which action is best, whereas positive morality sets forth habits, i.e. virtues, which lead to the achievement of values and methods for choosing what to value which is the way to live and thrive (Foot, 1978).
Anthropologists used to claim that morality, like law, is applied only within a society. It differs from etiquette, law, and religion. Morality is a code of conduct that is put forward by a society and provides a guide for the behavior of the people in that society. In this sense, morality might allow slavery or some people with one skin color to behave in ways that those with a different color are not allowed to behave. Many people, according to ethical relatives, refer morality to such a universal code of conduct.
Unlike the anthropologists, Kent (1967) claims that concept of morality is more closely tied to its religious origin. With one’s own life as the standard of value, morality is not a burden to bear, it is no unfortunate duty, but a prudent and effective guide which furthers life and success. With one’s life as the standard of value, morality is transformed from arbitrary mystical set of duties into a useful set of guidelines for how to live and flourish and achieve the best possible life.
Descriptively, morality has two essential features: that morality is a code of conduct that is put forward by a society and that it is used as a guide to behavior by the members of that society (Hare, 1981). In this sense, people can refer to an individual’s morality without endorsing it, so morality has no limitation on content. On the other hand, the Utilitarians talk about producing the greatest good as the goal of morality. However, they include the lessening of harm as essential to producing the greatest good and almost all of their examples involve the avoiding or preventing of harm. The paradigm cases of moral precepts involve rules which prohibit causing harm directly or indirectly, such as rules prohibiting killing, causing pain, deceiving, and breaking promises. When people explicitly talk about the morality of a group other than their own or of a person other than themselves, it is usually clear that they are using morality in a descriptive sense.
Definition of Morality The term, moral, came from a Greek word, moralis, which was first introduced by Cicero. To him this word is the equivalent of Aristotle’s ethikos (Bagus, 1996: 217). Bentham in his Principle of Moral and Legislation states nature has placed mankind under the governance of two sovereign masters, pain and pleasure. It is for them alone to point out what we ought to do, as well as to determine what we shall do. For Bentham it seems that mankind is caught up between getting pleasure and enduring pain. The morality of the person concerned is put on trial in the middle of this polarity between pleasure and pain.
Wallace defines morality as a doctrine or system of conduct relative to principles of right and wrong behavior. The word encompasses the ideas of: (i) moral judgment, with regard to behavior; (ii) moral obligation, referring to our conscience; and (iii) a moral agent, or one who is capable of right and wrong action. Common synonyms include ethics, principles, virtue and goodness. Morality can be a confusing topic in today's multi-cultural world. Let's explore what morality is, how it affects our behavior, and our conscience.
Morality and Our BehaviorMorality describes the principles that govern our behavior. Without these principles in place, societies cannot survive for long. In today's world, morality is frequently thought of as belonging to a particular religious point of view, but by definition, we see that this is not the case. Everyone adheres to a moral doctrine of some kind.
Morality as it relates to our behavior is important on three levels. Renowned thinker, scholar and author, Warnock defines them as: (1) to ensure fair play and harmony between individuals; (2) to help make us good people in order to have a good society; and (3) to keep us in a good relationship with the power that created us. Based on this definition, it's clear that our beliefs are critical to our moral behavior.
The view of many who do not adhere to Creation is that morality is an invention of man, based on the need to build cooperative societies. Since all life forms are constantly choosing between life and death, man's power to choose his actions is given reigning authority, ultimately leading to a code of values and virtues. But what happens when my choice conflicts with your choice? What if something I believe I need in order for my life to continue results in death for you? Without an absolute standard of truth, we are left to our own devices, with chaos the inevitable and ultimate destination.
Morality and Our ConscienceMorality affects our daily choices, and those decisions are guided by our conscience. Again, we must decide for ourselves where the conscience originates. Many people believe that our conscience is a matter of the heart, and that basic concepts of right, wrong and fairness are inherent in all of us.
Morality includes such values as honesty, the pursuit of truth, responsibility, duty, fairness in interpersonal relations, concern for one's immediate neighbors, respect for property, loyalty and duty to one's spouse and children, the work ethic and keeping one's word. The emphasis is upon the duty and responsibility of the individual.
No society can function efficiently or humanely and no civilization can endure, without these values. Honesty is essential for personal security. A lie is an abuse of another's faith. Lies demean the liar. Lies are at the root of unfair dealing and bad bargains. Therefore, lies stand at the root of personal oppression, conflict and litigation. Lies cover up worse sins and therefore prevent the rectification of wrongs.
Honesty to oneself is also important. It is necessary if one is to deal with reality (while there is time) instead of creating a world of illusion and self-deception which precludes all constructive response to problems and must inevitably lead to a greater debacle.
Dishonesty to oneself and one's neighbors has a way of returning upon one's own head. The liar creates a falsehood which he must ever go to greater lengths to maintain if he is to avoid public disgrace. It can become his living nightmare. At the same time he is less able to face up to his disgrace because his practice of lying corrodes the courage which he needs in order to face the truth.
The Symbol of Blood In Shakespeare's Macbeth the symbol of blood is used to represent honor, bravery, treason, murder, sin, and guilt. The symbol of blood is continuously developed until it becomes the dominating theme of the play.
The word "blood," or different forms of it appear forty-two times, throughout the play.
Perhaps the best way to show how the symbol of blood changes during the development of the play, is to follow the character changes in Macbeth. At first Macbeth is heralded as brave and honorable, but as the play progresses, he becomes a treacherous person who is identified with death and bloodshed, and shows his guilt in many different forms.
Honor and BraveryThe first reference of blood is one of honor, and occurs when Duncan sees the injured sergeant and says "What bloody man is that?".(Act I, Scene2,Line 1), This quote is symbolic of the brave fighter who had been injured during the battle for his country. In the next passage the Captain says "... Which smok'd with bloody execution, "(Act I, Scene 2, Line 20), he is referring to Macbeth's bravery in which his sword is covered in the hot blood of the enemy.
After these few references to honor, the symbol of blood now changes to show a theme of treachery and treason. Lady Macbeth starts this off when she asks the spirits to make her blood thick. What she is asking by this is, that she wants to make herself insensitive and remorseless for the deeds which she is about to commit.
TreasonLady Macbeth knows that the evidence of blood is a treacherous symbol, and knows it will make the servants and not she and Macbeth look guilty when she says ". . . smear the sleepy grooms with blood."(Act II, Scene 2, Lines 64-65), and ". . . If he do bleed, I"ll gild the faces of the grooms withal, for it must seem their guilt."(Act II, Scene2, Lines 81-83), When Banquo states " . . . and question this most bloody piece of work,"(Act II, Scene.3, Line 149), and then Ross says " . . . is't known who did this more than bloody deed?"(Act II, Scene 4, Line 28), they are both inquiring as to who performed the treacherous acts upon Duncan. When Macbeth is speaking about Malcolm and Donalbain, he refers to them as "bloody cousins."
Sin and Guilt
What is interesting in Macbeth related to the using image of blood. Blood symbolizes of sin and guilt that the main characters felt after killing king Duncan. Macbeth felt guilty, remorseful, and scared. The following quotation depicts Macbeth’s image of blood: “Will all great Neptune’s ocean wash this blood clean from my hand (Act II, Scene 2, Lines 60-61).
Here, Macbeth imagined that he still had Duncan’s blood on his hands, after he had washed them frenetically. He wondered if he would ever be able to forget the horrifying deed that he had committed. At the other time, the ghost of Bloody Banquo haunts him at the banquet. The sight of apparitions represents his guilt when he says: “It is the bloody business which informs thus” (Act II, scene I, 58-59). That quotation refers to his inability to say murder after he had killed king Duncan, so he uses the bloody business instead.
Then the ghost of Banquo, all gory, and bloody haunts Macbeth at the banquet. The sight of apparitions represents his guilt for the murder of Banquo which he planned. Macbeth shows a bit of his guilt when he says "It is the bloody business which informs thus,"(Act II, Scene 1, Lines 58-59), he could not gather up the courage to say murder after he had killed Duncan, so he uses this line instead.
The idea that the blood symbolizes guilty, in the play, is obviously expressed in Lady Macbeth. She shows the most vivid example of guilt using the image of blood on her hands that appear while sleep-walking. She says;
"Out damned spot! Out I say! One: two: why then "tis time to do"t: hell is murky. Fie, my lord, fie, a soldier, and afeard? What need we fear who knows it when none can call out power to account? Yet who would have thought the old man to have had so much blood in him?" (Act V, Scene 1, Lines 33-39).
That speech reveals that fact that she cannot wipe the blood of Duncan off her hands. She shows the motions of continuous washing of her hands which illustrates her guilty conscience after the murder. When the doctor of the castle finds out about her sleep-walking, he tells Macbeth: “As she is troubled with thick-coming fancies. That keep her from her rest” (Act II, Scene 3, Line 38-39). This means that Lady Macbeth has fantasies that deal with blood. Macbeth knows in his mind that she has troubles with her guilt, but he will not say anything about it. After this scene, Lady Macbeth goes crazy and dies in misery. Guilt, remorse, and fear are all emotions felt after seeing the blood of king Duncan.
Just before the ending of the play, Macbeth has Macduff at his mercy, and lets him go, because of his guilt. He shows that he is guilty, when he says "But get thee back, my soul is too much charg'd with blood of thine already."(Act V, Scene8, Lines 6-7). Of which, Macduff replies, "I have no words, my voice is in my sword, thou bloodier villain than terms can give thee out."(Act V, Scene8, Lines 8-10). He is saying that his actions with his sword will do his speaking for him and that Macbeth is the worst of all villains!
After the death of Macbeth at the hands of Macduff, the symbolic theme of blood swings back to what it was at the beginning of the play. It is the symbol of honor to Malcolm this time. The death of Macbeth is a honored feat that Macduff is congratulated for.
So as we have seen meaning of the symbol of blood change throughout the play from honor to treachery, and then to guilt, after this, it returns back to the symbolic meaning of honor once again. This could only occur after the villain that changed the meaning from honor to treachery is killed. Due to these many changes, it has been proved that the symbol of blood has many different meanings that can be attributed to the course of this historic play.
In brief, the blood imagery contributes to the overall atmosphere of darkness, deception, and horror experienced by both Macbeth and Lady Macbeth. The darkness and horror are shown by Macbeth’s sin and actions while in the dark. In addition the deception is depicted by their disloyalty towards the king and the entire kingdom.
AmbitiousThroughout history, man has shown an unhealthy desire for power. All humanity is ambitious. Every person wants the world to conform to his witches. As a product of the ego, this desire culminates in tyranny among those that have arrogance, opportunity, and instability to embrace and foster it. What a person craves for himself often determines his fate.
Reading Macbeth by William Shakespeare, one could easily infer that with the opportunity, arrogance, and instability which are bred by his ego and contra natural forces Macbeth changes his characters. His blind ambition for the pursuit of power and control disregards his moral. Macbeth essentially loses his integrity and honor as a direct result of his own actions. He is a man, who for the simple sake of his own ambition, is willing to murder many people including his king and his best friend.
Furthermore, he adhered to the evil whims and plans of his wife, and put himself in a position that destroyed his self respect, ruined his pride, degraded his honor, and spoiled his integrity in order to possess and maintain the crown. His ambition is stronger than his conscience. Along with his crown, he comes to his downfall. This happens because of his ambition for the throne, an ambition that will do anything in order to behold.
Lady Macbeth is fascinating portrait of an ambitious wife. She is ambitious not for herself, but for her husband. Lady Macbeth wants Macbeth to be a great and powerful man. She loves him and her only ambition is to help him gain the throne of Scotland. She uses all her strength and intelligence for evil purposes. She helps Macbeth overcome his natural and hesitation to commit murder. She is feeding herself with day-dreams of ambition.
She is bold and confident, because she does not understand that her ambition is morally wrong. Her only concern is to destroy the evidence. She is a strong woman by saying that behind every great man there is a woman. Lady Macbeth wants Macbeth to be a great and powerful man. She thinks that Macbeth will be less of a person if he does not steal the throne. Even she dubs him a coward for not wanting to carry out their murder plan. (Was the hope drunk Wherein you dress’s yourself? hath it slept since? And wakes in now, to look so green and pale At what it did so freely? From this time Such I account thy love, art thou afraid To be the same in thy own act and valour As though art in desire? Would’st thou have that which thou esteem’t of life, And live a coward in their own esteem, Act I, Scene 7, Lines 35-43).
Powerful ContradictionMacbeth is a character of powerful contradiction. He is not only strong and courageous but also very ambitious. At first, he is brave, noble, and loyal thane. However, his character changes drastically after the witches tempt him with the idea of becoming king. They have predicted something which stirs a deep chord of response in his being. Their prediction comes to his mind: “ Glamis, and Thane of Cawdor ! The Greatest is behind” (Act I, Scene 3, Line 117-118). Being the name of Thane of Cawdor after absorbing the three witches prophesies strengthened Macbeth’s sole ambition to have the throne of Scotland for himself.
Macbeth is somewhat uneasy and feels that he wants fate alone to hand him the throne, rather than killing King Duncan himself to inherit it.( If chance will have me king, chance may crown me, without my stir, Act 1, Scene 3, Lines 142-144). Macbeth undergoes dilemma at that time, between his honor and the crown. There is an inner conflict inside Macbeth, a sign of his actions, but more truthfully questions the probability of success.
He is not at all concerned with whether what he is doing is right, he only cares about whether he will succeed. However, during the banquet held at Macbeth’s castle at Inverness in honour of Duncan, his ambition changes. He contemplates his wicked plan of executing Duncan and arrives at the conclusion of not allowing his plan to fall through. His ambition increases when King Duncan announces his oldest son, Malcolm, the Prince of Cumberland, to be the heir to the Scottish throne. Consequently, for his desire to become king, he is willing to turn his back on what he knows to be right.
MonstrousMacbeth does horrible things. He murders his king, who is also his own uncle. Once he has killed to get the crown, the other crimes seem inevitable. In order to keep what he has taken, Macbeth learns to lie and kill as a matter of course. His values become totally confused. “Fair is foul, and foul is fair” (Act I, Scene1, Line 11). To him now, he has lost track of the difference. In addition, he hires men to kill his best friend, general Banquo. He sends men to kill Macduff’s wife and son.
Having taken the crown by murder, he keeps it by deception. He plants spies in all the noble’s homes and spreads lies about Malcolm, king Duncan’s son, who should rightfully inherit the throne. He rules by terror since he does not deserve anybody’s loyalty. His violent acts and criminal activities simply the result of his blind ambition to be the king. His ambition is driven by the prophecies of the three witches. he is wrong to hear their prophecies as an invitation to murder the king. Their evil forces eventually destroy Macbeth's oral.
William Shakespeare depicts the two main characters, Macbeth and Lady Macbeth, as overly ambitious, deceptive, and dishonest. To my subjective interpretation in Macbeth, Shakespeare creates an atmosphere of darkness, deception, and horror by using images of blood, the supernatural, and darkness, which causes the death of the two main characters.
Supernatural Another interesting image used by Shakespeare is the coming of the supernatural. As it was mentioned earlier, Macbeth’s character changes drastically after having got the witches’s prophesies. The supernatural, witches, and apparition play an important role on Macbeth’s character because they influence much Macbeth while in his egotistical state of mind.
Macbeth slaughters many people of importance to the kingdom, one of them is Banquo, the other army general and Macbeth’s best friend. Banquo is the only one who knows the secret of the witches’ prophecies on macbeth. The death of Banquo haunted Macbeth. While being crowned in a room full of sergeants, army members, and his wife, he sees banquo’s ghost. He becomes hysterical. He states: “Thou art too like a spirit of Banquo. Down ! “ (Act IV, Scene1, Line 113).
Although Macbeth deceives others, on the contrary, the witches manipulate and deceive Macbeth by remarking him as Thane of Glamis, Thane of Cawdor, and the king. Notice the following quotation: “All hail, Macbeth! Hail to thee, Thane of Glamis ! All hail, Macbeth! Hail to thee, Thane of Cawdor ! All hail, Macbeth, that shall be King hereafter!” (Act I, Scene 3, Lines 48-50).
The second prophecy tells that Macbeth cannot be killed or harmed by normal man. Thus he must be inhuman in order to win the kingdom. See the following speech: “Be bloody, bold, and resolute, laugh to scorn The power of man, for none of woman born shall harm Macbeth” (Act IV, Scene 1, Lines 79-81). Receiving the prophecies that he is safe from any man born of woman, Macbeth feels himself invincible. Maddened by power, which he has usurped, Macbeth fails to realize that the power he has taken contra naturally will be returned
It seems that the images of ghosts and witches all contribute to darkness, deception, and horror. The atmosphere of darkness is depicted as the only time when the witches come out to talk with Macbeth. It plays an important role in the supernatural. Moreover, the atmosphere of deception occurs when the witches lead Macbeth in the wrong direction of his life.
The horror, eventually, is illustrated on Macbeth’s face when he finds that Macduff, whose wife and son were killed by the murderers assigned by himself, is not born of a woman. Macduff, in addition, explains the nature of his birth: a Caesarean operation. He was not born by the efforts of a woman but was from his ‘mother’s womb/untimely ripped’. Notice the next quotation : “I bear a charmed life; which must not yield. To one of woman born” (Act V, Scene 8, Lines 12-13). The existence of the bloody body of Duncan contributes to the state of horror.
NatureNature plays an important role in the play, because it reflects and reacts to the actions of Macbeth. His lack of moral conscience affects nature. The notional image of horses eating one another is inexplicable: “Turned wild in nature, break their , flung out, contending ’against obedience” (II.4.17-18). The image of a falcon eating an owl for no apparent reason is another example. An old man speaks of this; “’This unnatural, ... a falcon towering in her pride of space was by a mousing owl hawked at and killed!” (II.4.10-13)
As a result of Macbeth’s effect on nature, Lady Macbeth speaks about noticing unusual occurrences seen while walking. “I heard the owl scream and the crickets cry” (II.2.16). The actions of the animals are metaphors for man and woman’s rage for power and control. All examples illustrate the effects Macbeth’s sins have on the kingdom and nature.
Nature incorporates the all-around atmosphere of darkness, deception, and horror. Darkness is part of nature. It helps set the mood. All of the incomprehensible acts occur during the night. Deception comes into play when Macbeth’s deeds and ambitions end up taking nature off its course. He has taken a turn for the worse, and nature is just following suit. The horror of seeing the indescribable scene of horses eating one another is not very easy to swallow. It also shows the unforgivable crime he has committed.
DarknessDarkness reveals the most important image in Macbeth. It is used as a tool to hide sins and deeds of both Macbeth and Lady macbeth. The portrait of night influences Lady Macbeth to call upon it to cover her bad actions. Read the following quotation :
“Come, thick night, and pall there in the dunnest smoke of Hell” (Act I, Scene 5, Lines 46-47).
The above quotation comes after Macbeth gets success in killing king Duncan. Lady Macbeth asks Macbeth to use the bloody knife to kill the king’s guards in order to frame them for his death. Time has gone and past, yet it is still day. When it is supposed to be night, the stars are not appearing. Through the above speech, William Shakespeare describes that the two main characters’ actions have set the dark atmosphere for the whole play. The dark image contributes to overall atmosphere of darkness, deception, and horror.
Darkness is the key to Macbeth’s killing on king Duncan, because he does not want anyone to see him. Darkness, furthermore, is called upon to cover up the murdering of Duncan. Deception comes into the story when the actual stabbing of king Duncan occurs. Macbeth kills his king, who thought of him as a loyal sergeant, host, and kinsmen, but in actuality wanted to be king.
At last Macbeth learns a valuable lesson that greed, deception, and disloyalty get nothing. His ambition for the throne costs his own life. He undergoes tragic flaw, that is, his downfall as the result of his ambition. In addition, Lady Macbeth could not live with her horrible deeds. Covering her guilty conscience, she takes her own life. The images of blood, the supernatural, and darkness cause the demise of the two main characters to be even more horrific.
ConclusionThree moral lessons that Shakespeare’s audience would have taken with them after reading the play are power corrupts, do not give in to the temptations of evil, and one murder can snowball into a large mess.
In the beginning of the play, Macbeth was a very successful general of King Duncan’s army. He was a good person, loyal, with much ability. After having got the prophecies from the three witches that he would become the king hereafter, Macbeth’s thirst for power erupted. With the influence much of Lady Macbeth, he became a cold-blooded killer, and went insane. This is an absolute waste of talent. He went so quickly from a marvelous, courageous army leader to an insane murderer, that one can clearly see how power can corrupt.
Throughout Macbeth, Shakespeare shows how the supernatural forces in the play are much stronger than the individual character. The witches may be evil but their prophecies convey truth. The witches’ prophecies sound like good news, however, they lead to death and destruction. Macbeth, at first, was careful of the three witches, but after their second meeting, he began to rely on their evil ways. The evil forces that eventually claim him corrupt Macbeth. He is culpable for his actions and the blame lies solely on him. Throughout the play, Shakespeare points how greatly evil forces can effect characters by robbing them of their humanity. Macbeth is victimized by these evil forces and is tricked into destroying himself. He appears to achieve his heart’s desires; in fact, he only gains torment and death. The play suggests that a person should trust his destiny to a higher power not to evil forces. After having trusted much to the three witches, Macbeth tries to take fate into his own hands, and that action brings him nothing but grief. We can see how misleading the witches were to Macbeth.
Once Macbeth kills king Duncan to get the crown, the other crimes seem inevitable. He is committed to a course of lying and killing. His actions are monstrous. Having taken the crown by murder, he keeps it by deception He plants spies in all the nobles' homes and spreads lies about Malcolm, who should rightfully inherit the throne. Macbeth rules by terror, since he does not deserve--or have--anybody's loyalty. He had killed at least seven more people. If Macbeth was not such a head case, he would not have murdered Duncan in the first place, and seven other people would have lived. In order to keep his power, he had to murder his own best friend, Banquo. If Macbeth had let fate take its course, there would not have been such a mess to deal with the first place. All of the evil that Macbeth has committed finally catches up with him. He gets just desserts when he is killed.
Bibliography- Abrams, M.H. 1987. A Glossary of Literary Terms. New York: Holt, Rinehart and Winston, Inc.
- Bagus, Lorenz. 1996. Kamus Filsafat. Jakarta: Gramedia.
- Brown, Calvin S. 1956. The Reader’s Companion to World Literature. The Dryden Press, Inc.
- Foot, Phillipa. 1978. Virtues and Vices, and Other Essays in Moral Philosophy. Berkeley: University of California Press.
- Hare, R.M. 1981. Moral Thinking. New York: Oxford University Press.
- Hicks, Malcolm; Hutchings, Bill. 1989. Literary Criticism. Chapman and Hall, Inc.
- Jones, Edward H. 1968. Outlines of Literature. New York. The Macmillan Company.
- Kant, Immanuel. 1967. Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals. New York: Barness & Noble.
- Kermode. et all. 1973. The Oxford Anthology of English Literature. Volume I. Oxford University Press.
- Mill, John Stuart. 1998. Ulitiarianism. Edited by Roger Crisp. New York. Oxford University Press.
- Neilson, William Allan; Hill, Charles Jarvis. 1942. The Complete Plays and Poetry of William Shakespeare. Houghton Mifflin Company.
- Pickering, James H.; Hooper, Jeffrey D. 1981. Concise Companion to Literature. New York. Macmillan Publishing Co., Inc.
- Sampson, George. 1959. The Concise Cambridge History of English Literature. The Syndics of the Cambridge University Press.
- Wallace, G. and Walker,A.D.M. editors. 1970. The Definition of Morality. London.Methuen.
- Warren, Austin; Welleck, Rene. 1977. Theory of Literature. New York: A Harvest/HBJ Book, Harcourt Brace Yohanovich.